Can beggars be choosers?

“You look at them with such pity,” Diego snapped.

I hurriedly averted my eyes from the forlorn figure of a tramp, huddled beneath his blanket in a filthy shop doorway.

“Oh, it’s an English thing,” I said hurriedly.

“They usually have dogs and you know how English people feel about dogs.”

“No, you feel sorry for them,” Diego replied.

“There is no reason to feel sorry for them.”

I opened my mouth to argue.

“No,” my Colombian friend continued.

“They all came here when there was trouble in the countryside.

“But the countryside is safe now. They should either go back or find work here in Bogotá.”

I started a valiant protest.

“But you don’t know that’s the case with every tramp,” I pleaded.

“Some of them might have been abused at home. If I was abused I’d have run away too and ended up on the streets.

“Then it’s pretty difficult to find work.”

“No way,” my friend interjected.

“I speak to these guys. They speak as many languages as I do.

(Diego speaks five languages at the last count)

“There is no way they can’t find work,” he continued.

“They’re just lazy.”

I opened my mouth to continue the argument.

“You’re wrong,” my friend said firmly, before I could speak.

I let the matter drop, but I didn’t forget it.

I noticed that some of Diego’s friends gave money to beggars.

I also noticed that all of the cab drivers in Bogotá keep a small stash of coins beside their steering wheel, ready to hand out at the traffic lights.

Still, I’m not one to give money to people on the streets.

Although I always tried to remember to buy my Big Issue at home, handing out cash generally means opening your purse in public. I don’t think that’s too smart.

But today was different.

I was in a very good mood and the sun was warm on my face.

A young man, with ragged clothes and shining eyes, stopped me just outside the supermarket.

“Please mum, give me some money for food,” he begged in Spanish.

Maybe it was the shining eyes beneath the grime that stopped me.

Or perhaps it was because he was about my age and he still called me ‘mum’.

I opened my wallet and delivered my usual sermon designed to make beggars feel even worse than they already do.

“No smoking and no alcohol,” I insisted in Spanish.

Why should beggars be allowed any vices to alleviate their suffering?

“I don’t smoke and I don’t drink,” the beggar replied, in perfect English.

I was stunned.

“You speak English?” I exclaimed.

The beggar smiled proudly.

“Yes mum,” he said, nodding his head earnestly.

“And I also speak French.”


  1. Marieke

    Diego sure was right there. Wonder though why live on the streets and beg, what happened in their lives that they prefer this over a home..

    1. bananaskinflipflops

      I don’t know. I’m still of the view that if you don’t have an address, clean clothes – even a bank account – it’s almost impossible to get a job, even if you speak Japanese!! If people have been displaced because of the civil war, they might not have homes to go back to… I remain a softie, Diego remains resolute.

  2. David Lozano

    first i want to congratulate for your blog. i live in bogota, and i recently found this space and i`m happy with what you have written. ( excuse me if my english is not good enough)


    about this topic i think that there is people that choose this activity but i think it is the minority. against what the statistics show, the unemployment rate is high and the prospects for sustaining a home with the minimum wage are minimal…there are many reasons about that situation, and in a city like this you can find different kind of persons…

    again thanks for this blog, and to talk about the good things that Colombia, and Bogota have.

    if you need something of a political scientist, you can count on me. my email is good bye.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s